Whats the difference between working with an independent agent vs. a captive agent such as State Farm or Farmers?

The answer is simple. We give you options.

How can I make a payment over the phone?

For all billing questions or to make a payment over the phone, here is a list of numbers you can call.

  • SafeCo Policies – 1.800.332.3226
  • Travelers Policies – 1.800.842.5075
  • Foremost Policies – 1.800.532.4221
  • Allstate Policies – 1.800.901.1731
  • Mercury Policies – 1.800.503.3724 or 1.866.637.2176

How much insurance coverage do I need?

Every situation is unique, it depends; on what type of vehicle you drive, do you make payments on your vehicle, how much your can afford, and how much you have to protect. We would love to sit down and create a custom plan for you.

What does full coverage include?

Full coverage includes comprehensive and collision protection. There are various other coverages you can include such as uninsured motorist, roadside assistance, medical payments, and rental car coverage that you can add or subtract from your plan.

What is Uninsured Motorist coverage, and how do I know if I need it?

In the state of Oklahoma, Uninsured Motorist coverage is optional. It covers your medical expenses in the event you are hit by someone who does not carry auto insurance. According to Oklahoma had the highest number of uninsured motorists at 26%. We recommend doing your due diligence before adding or subtracting any coverages and we would love to help you do that!

How can I file a claim?

If you have a claim you need to file, or a question regarding an open claim, please see below for a list of phone numbers to call.

  • SafeCo Policies – 1.800.332.3226
  • Travelers Policies – 1.800.252.4633
  • Foremost Policies – 1.800.274.7865
  • Allstate Policies – 1.800.255.7828
  • Mercury Policies – 1.800.503.3274

How can I find a better rate?

Call our office at 918.877.2624. We have a staff dedicated to understanding your situation and helping you get the best rate and coverages.

How can I pay my bill online?

Create an online account through your specific insurance company. Please see a list below:


How often should I shop my rate?

We recommend that you shop your rate once every two years.

How many companies does Williams Insurance Group write policies for?

We have 20 companies. We can shop your policy through any of them at any time to make sure you are getting the best rate and coverages for your needs.